West Midlands Strategic Health Authority

Home ] Up ] The Campaign ] Petitions ] Events index ] Health Policy ] Democracy ] The NHS ] Talks Letters & Articles ] Contacts and Further Reading ]
 

The West Midlands Strategic Health Authority was formed on 1 July 2006.  Where possible reports will continue to be shown under:

Birmingham and The Black Country Strategic Health Authority
Shropshire and Staffordshire Strategic Health Authority
West Midlands South Strategic Health Authority

See also Warwickshire and Coventry Local News

  • Hospitals 'opt out' of IT system. Some NHS trusts are opting out of offering patients a choice of hospital under a new IT system being rolled out, according to family doctors. GPs said they are unable to book appointments using the online system, Choose and Book, for hospitals with long waiting lists. They said hospitals did not want to exceed the 13-week diagnosis target, and it was interfering with choice. From the beginning of this year, patients have been given the choice of at least four local hospitals for treatment. This has been subsequently expanded to include foundation hospitals and a range of private clinics. In some of the places it has been introduced, such as Yorkshire, the Midlands and the south west, family doctors said hospitals with waits exceeding 13 weeks for diagnostic tests are not being put on the system. Summary by Keep our NHS Public of BBC Online 9 August 2006
  • NHS plc: a dire diagnosis. Private Eye says: "No sooner had a cross-party committee of MPs heavily criticised the government's use of independent sector treatment centres (ISTCs) than the Department of Health defiantly announced that these private sector companies would be given £lbn worth of contracts to run a series of "diagnostic centres". The identities of the lucky firms show how commercial the business of healthcare has become. The London and east England contract goes to Amicus InHealth… owned by a consortium of South African private health outfit Netcare, which botched a contract to provide cataract operations in Oxfordshire; Apax, a private equity group set up by New Labour favourite Sir Ronald Cohen; and Inhealth, a company chaired by serial private health director Tim Chessells and owned by a mysterious Luxembourg fund called Pegasus. Doubtless this bunch has nothing but the nation's health in mind as it makes crucial diagnoses and won't be unduly inclined to push people to independent treatment centres of the sort run by, er, Netcare. Meanwhile in the South West the record of the (management) consultants at Atos Origin in providing the over-priced and unpopular choose-and-book system for hospital referrals was no bar to their success. Nor in the South East were there too many concerns about the conflicts of interest presented by handing the diagnosis deal to the country's biggest private hospital operator, the taxdodging BUPA. West Midlands patients will be able to benefit from the services of Mercury Healthcare, the company that has already been paid millions for work it hasn't done and whose "group strategy director" is one Mark Smith, the former chief executive of Portsmouth Hospitals NHS trust who resigned after the trust received zero stars. From there he became head of health at PFI firm Amey working closely with Ken Anderson... who now just happens to be doling out the diagnostic centre contracts as "commercial director" of the NHS. Appropriately enough in the North East the diagnostics contract has gone to Alliance Medical, the company owned by yet another private equity group, Bridgepoint - former employer of Geordie New Labour man and ex-Health Secretary Alan Milburn. The company's previous forays into the health service include a £95m contract to run MRI scans which were so poor they had to be checked by the NHS anyway, leading the British Medical Association to describe the firm's performance as "a complete disaster". So depending on where you live, your next illness could well be diagnosed by an incompetent or a profiteer - or more likely a combination of the two." Summary by Keep our NHS Public of Private Eye 16 August 2006
  • Blair talks tough on hospital cuts. Tony Blair has warned hospital trusts in the West Midlands that they must live within their means and take "difficult decisions" in a changing NHS. Hospital trusts across the region - including Shrewsbury & Telford and Worcestershire Acute - are planning cuts in staff and services to try to get their books back into balance. The Shrewsbury and Telford Hospital Trust is currently carrying debts of more than £31m and is cutting nearly 300 posts at the Royal Shrewsbury Hospital and Princess Royal Hospital in Telford. Blair said: "It's absolutely true that where there are deficits it concentrates the minds of people about what's wrong in their area. It focuses minds on changes that need to happen. These difficult decisions are being replicated in every walk of life, but the test is 'do you get a better service ?' Are we saying that the NHS - uniquely of any other organisation - has to remain exactly as it is, and if you change it, you are destroying the service ? That cannot be right, and it does not happen in any other walk of life." Summary by Keep our NHS Public of Shropshire Star 19 October 2006
  • NHS to restore health at Tribal. Mercury Health, the healthcare delivery arm of struggling public sector outsourcing specialist Tribal, has won preferred bidder status for a "substantial five-year contract" to provide a range of surgical, orthodontic, rehabilitation, sexual health and family planning services to NHS patients in Essex. It is already contracted to design, build and manage five other NHS centres for diagnostic procedures and surgery. Tribal said the Mercury deal was for 29,000 procedures and appointments annually in Essex. Mercury Health chief executive Peter Martin said: "This announcement extends our partnership with the NHS and builds on recent success in being chosen as preferred bidder for a major diagnostics contract treating NHS patients in the West Midlands." Summary by Keep our NHS Public of Western Daily Press 14 December 2006
  • Nurses leave for Australia in thousands as NHS halts recruitment. Thousands of nurses are leaving Britain to work abroad after being headhunted by international recruitment teams. Hospitals and nursing agencies in Australia and other countries are encouraging British health workers to emigrate in an attempt to capitalise on a shortage of jobs in the NHS, the country's top nurse has said. Many local NHS trusts have imposed a recruitment freeze as the health service struggles to balance its books before the end of the financial year. An estimated 20,000 nursing posts have been cut in hospitals and surgeries across the country, leaving many newly qualified nurses out of work. Peter Carter, the new general secretary of the Royal College of Nursing, described the situation as shambolic, saying that he knew of nearly 100 nurses from the West Midlands alone who left to work in Australia this week. This is despite an anticipated shortfall of 14,000 trained nurses in the NHS by 2010, he said. Last year, about 3,000 nurses and midwives left Britain to work in Australia - more than double the number making the same trip ten years ago - making it the most popular destination for the 8,000 nurses who emigrated to work abroad. Dr Carter said that Britain was facing a "massive skills shortage" as a result of the Government's "yo-yo work-force planning" and predicted that British hospitals would soon have to recruit nurses from abroad to make up staff numbers. About 180,000 British nurses are due to retire over the next ten years, according to a leaked government report last month. Summary by Keep our NHS Public of Times 17 February 2007
  • MRSA superbug strain kills two. A form of the superbug MRSA has killed patients in a British hospital for the first time, public health officials said today. Two people - a patient and a healthcare worker - died in September at a West Midlands hospital after contracting the aggressive strain of MRSA, the Health Protection Agency (HPA) said. An investigation by the HPA, which monitors infectious diseases, found eight people tested positive for Panton-Valentine Leukocidin community-associated MRSA, commonly known as PVL. Four of those people developed an infection, two of whom subsequently died. David Batty and agencies Monday December 18, 2006 Guardian Unlimited
  • PCTs delayed on audiology contract. An audiology contract has been delayed indefinitely because the provider has not been able to sign off quality and safety guarantees with the Department of Health. The DoH had awarded Mercury Health preferred bidder status to provide diagnostics services to NHS patients across the West Midlands, on behalf of the region's 17 primary care trusts. However the delay in the audiology contract has left PCTs fearful that they may miss next year's 18-week maximum wait target. A DoH spokesman said Mercury Health had not yet shown that it could 'ensure patient safety and high-quality healthcare for NHS patients'. The contract would only proceed when this had been guaranteed, he said. The DoH's contract with Mercury Health to provide other types of diagnostics services to patients in the West Midlands will start at the end of May, two months after the government's original deadline. In February, HSJ revealed that BUPA had pulled out of a contract with the DoH to provide diagnostic services across the South East. Amicus InHealth, a joint venture between Amicus Healthcare and InHealth Group, has won preferred bidder status on two of the diagnostics contracts in London and the East of England. Atos Origin will provide diagnostic services to patients in the South West, and Alliance Medical has won preferred bidder status for the North East. Summary by Keep our NHS Public of Health Service Journal 5 April 2007
  • Private centre delay hits PCTs. PCTs face missing waiting list targets and will have to find funds to commission alternative services after the Department of Health delayed the opening of a new independent sector treatment centre. The centre, in the West Midlands, was due to start providing an audiology service on 26 March, but primary care trust staff found out on the Friday before that it would not be ready. The department said the delay had been caused because health and safety guarantees had not been signed off by the provider, Mercury Health. Now some PCTs are being forced to recommission services from existing providers for fear that they may incur delays and extra expense. Summary by Keep our NHS Public of Pulse 20 April 2007
  • Setback for NHS on treatment centres. Nuffield Hospitals, the not-for-profit private hospital operator, has pulled out of negotiations to provide operations for NHS patients using mobile operating theatres in the West Midlands. The move is a setback for the Department of Health's drive to get up to an extra 250,000 patients a year treated in private sector facilities through a second round of independent sector treatment centres (ISTCs). Some 13 schemes have reached preferred bidder stage but it is now nearly two years since they were first announced, with none having yet reached financial close. Nuffield cited costs and delays in concluding the deal as the reason behind its decision. A series of factors, including negotiations between the department and the Treasury, have slowed the deals, with some in the private sector uncertain whether Gordon Brown will promote the programme with the same vigour as Tony Blair, assuming the chancellor succeeds him as prime minister. David Mobbs, Nuffield's chief executive, said the scheme was originally due to go live this month. But "delays have seen our costs and risks rise" to the point where already slim margins on the contract were being rapidly eroded. With no firm contract in sight, he said, the company had decided to draw a line under the deal. He insisted that the decision did not imply a loss of interest in doing work for the NHS. "We are still extremely excited about the NHS market and about the increasing right of patients to choose a private hospital." In addition, primary care trusts in the Midlands were still showing "a high degree of interest" in the project, he said, and Nuffield still hoped to use the mobile theatres for NHS patients under locally agreed arrangements. The Department of Health now has the choice of dropping the deal or attempting to persuade its reserve bidder, thought to be Netcare, to take it on. The move comes as most of the companies bidding for the second wave of ISTCs now say privately that they do not believe the programme will reach the government's original - and repeatedly confirmed - target of spending £550m a year to treat 250,000 patients annually. Most now expect it to add up to only £350m. But the private sector's faith in a continuing market for NHS care was demonstrated by the completion yesterday of Care UK's deal to buy Mercury, which also runs treatment centres and a range of other services for the NHS, from the Tribal Group. The deal has cost Care UK £77m once debt repayments and debt assumed are included. Mike Parish, Care UK's chief executive, said: "You don't get that sort of money back from the residual period of Mercury's existing contracts. This represents a substantial investment [in our belief] that there will be life [in work for the NHS] after the existing contracts." Summary by Keep our NHS Public of Financial Times 21 April 2007
  • Residents targeted in ambulance shake-up. Midlands residents have been urged to look at a document detailing plans to close two of the region's 999 call centres. Over 1,000 copies are being provided to NHS organisations, patients' groups and ambulance stations. West Midlands Ambulance Service announced last month that it wished to move staff from Shrewsbury and Bransford, near Worcester, to the region's three other centres as part of a reconfiguration of services. Ambulance unions have claimed that the move could lead to worse response times due to a lack of local knowledge of areas such as the Malvern Hills, as well as redundancies. Unison is considering balloting members after claiming that they had not been consulted o the plans. Health bosses have countered claiming that "scaremongering statements" were unduly worrying the public, and that there would be no job losses. Sir Graham Meldrum, WMAS chairman, said: "While the trust recognises this is a difficult time for staff, we have given a commitment that there will be no redundancies." He added: "There have been a number of scaremongering statements issued in relation to the proposed changes which are unhelpful and misleading. Local knowledge will be protected and enhanced through the use of new technology which is already saving lives with other services. We want to create a world class emergency service, but to do so we have to make changes." A number of meetings are to be held to discuss the proposals ahead of a decision in October. Murray McGregor, a trust spokesman, added: "This is what we think is the best option, but if people have other views, we want to hear them. However the importance of local knowledge has been overstated. To say operators in Worcester or Shrewsbury know everything is wrong, they don't, and the occasions where such knowledge is needed are minimal." Summary by Keep our NHS Public of Birmingham Post 17 July 2007
  • Three suspended in ambulance row. Three West Midlands Ambulance Service staff in Shropshire have been suspended over information passed to the BBC. The service said it was investigating a possible breach of the Data Protection Act after control room logs were shown to journalists at BBC Radio Shropshire. It comes amid concerns over plans to close the ambulance control room in Shrewsbury and instead have two centres in Stafford and the Black Country. Some staff believe that such a move would put lives at risk. Control logs seen by BBC staff apparently showed ambulances were sent from Shropshire to help in Birmingham and the Black Country, reducing the number of emergency vehicles available in the county. Ambulance bosses have written to the BBC asking reporters to reveal the source of the documents passed to the corporation. The suspended members of staff have been told that if allegations against them prove to be true they would be guilty of gross misconduct. BBC 31 July 2007
  • Ambulance suspensions criticised. An MP has given his backing to three ambulance staff suspended after information was passed to the BBC. Control room logs suggested ambulances from Shropshire were being sent to help in Birmingham and the Black Country. Three staff were then suspended by West Midlands Ambulance Service as part of an investigation into a possible breech of the Data Protection Act. Daniel Kawczinsky, MP for Shrewsbury and Atcham, said he was worried staff were being "intimidated". It comes amid concerns over plans to close the ambulance control room in Shrewsbury and instead have two centres in Stafford and the Black Country. He said: "These issues are of fundamental importance to my constituents and the people of Shropshire and they should be aired. I personally am deeply concerned that people are being intimidated in this way. It is absolutely scandalous. I don't want to live in a society where people who provide frontline services to my constituents [and] who have genuine concerns or fears about safety issues cannot and... are not allowed to speak out. That's not a democratic society and that's why I will fight tooth and nail for their right to do this." He said he was writing to Health Secretary Alan Johnson about his concerns. West Midlands Ambulance Service has said it was concerned that patient confidentiality had been broken by the leak but has refused to comment further until an investigation is completed. It has written to the BBC asking reporters to reveal the source of the documents passed to the corporation. The BBC has refused to do this, saying it is not prepared to reveal confidential sources.  BBC 2 August 2007
  • Ambulance call took six minutes. An ambulance trust has admitted call centre staff took six minutes to answer a telephone call. A trust spokesman said the call to the West Midlands Ambulance centre in Brierley Hill, Dudley, was made during a busy period on the evening of 18 May. He said: "Clearly, this is something we are concerned about." West Midlands Ambulance Service NHS Trust has since taken on 32 new call centre staff and June figures show 98% of calls were answered in five seconds. The delay in answering the call had no repercussions for the patient, he said.   BBC 7 August 2007
  • Two ambulance workers re-instated. Two West Midlands Ambulance Service workers who were suspended over an alleged breach of the Data Protection Act will be allowed to return to work. The service said the pair had been re-instated, pending the results of an inquiry, after holding interviews with them and Unison officials on Tuesday. Talks are planned next week with a third worker who was also suspended. The staff, who are based in Shropshire, were sent home last week after control room logs were obtained by the BBC.    BBC 7 August 2007
  • Ambulance staff management vote. West Midlands Ambulance Service staff are being balloted to see if they have confidence in their management. The move, by Unison, follows concerns about the suspension of three ambulance staff in Shropshire. Two workers have now had their suspensions lifted, and a third will meet for talks next week. Some staff said they are also concerned about proposals to close the Shrewsbury call centre and move to Brierley Hill in the Black Country. The workers, who were suspended over an alleged breach of the Data Protection Act, were sent home last week after control room logs were obtained by the BBC. The logs suggested ambulances from the county were being sent to help in Birmingham and the Black Country.     BBC 8 August 2007
  • Seven private NHS clinics to be dropped. Gordon Brown was yesterday accused of cooling on the public services reform programme championed by Tony Blair, as the health department announced it was slashing plans for more private sector treatment in the NHS. The Confederation of British Industry accused ministers of handing "an early Christmas present to opponents of reform". But the health secretary, Alan Johnson, defended the scrapping of seven planned independent treatment schemes, saying the decision was not ideological but taken on the grounds of value for money. Johnson announced that the second wave of independent-sector treatment centres would involve only three new schemes worth £200m, a third of the previously estimated £600m in contracts. He also announced that one of the first-wave centres, a diagnostic service run by Care UK in the West Midlands, would be closed after it achieved just 5% takeup. Patrick Wintour, political editor The Guardian Friday November 16 2007
  • Junior doctors fear life on the dole. More than 4,000 junior doctors in the West Midlands fear unemployment due to increased competition for jobs. Experts predict that less than a third will achieve the posts they trained for in the region. The British Medical Association has blamed the government for failing to manage staffing effectively. A spokesman said: "They have increased medical school places while reducing actual medical posts which can be taken up at the end. It's ridiculous. Taxpayers' money is being wasted and junior doctors who want to put their training to good use are being forced to make huge sacrifices." Some medics have described how the training fiasco has effectively split their families by forcing them to take posts far from home. Dr Masood Ahmed, from the West Midlands Junior Doctors Committee, said: "There are currently about 4,000 in the West Midlands facing an employment lottery when it comes for them to find posts to continue their training. Families are being split up over this." A spokeswoman for the Department of Health said: "There are many lessons to be learned from problems with junior doctors' recruitment last year. We are determined to listen to the voices of doctors and make changes to the process in 2008 and subsequent years. However, the scope for change in 2008 is limited. Major changes would need more time for development and piloting will be considered for 2009." Summary by Keep our NHS Public of Sunday Mercury 13 January 2008

Heat Map for West Midlands
SHA forecasts 2006 07 West Midlands

Annual Health Check 2006

Healthcare organisations weak for quality of services

Oldbury and Smethwick Primary Care Trust
Rowley Regis and Tipton Primary Care Trust
Staffordshire Ambulance Service NHS Trust
Wednesbury and West Bromwich Primary Care Trust
West Midlands Ambulance Service NHS Trust

Healthcare organisations weak for use of resources

Burntwood, Lichfield and Tamworth Primary Care Trust
Coventry Teaching Primary Care Trust
Dudley South Primary Care Trust
George Eliot Hospital NHS Trust
Good Hope Hospital NHS Trust
Newcastle-Under-Lyme Primary Care Trust
North Birmingham Primary Care Trust
North Stoke Primary Care Trust
Oldbury and Smethwick Primary Care Trust
Rowley Regis and Tipton Primary Care Trust
Rugby Primary Care Trust
Sandwell and West Birmingham Hospitals NHS Trust
Shrewsbury and Telford Hospitals NHS Trust
South Warwickshire General Hospitals NHS Trust
South Western Staffordshire Primary Care Trust
South Worcestershire Primary Care Trust
Staffordshire Moorlands Primary Care Trust
The Royal Wolverhampton Hospitals NHS Trust
University Hospital of North Staffordshire NHS Trust
West Midlands Ambulance Service NHS Trust
Worcestershire Acute Hospitals NHS Trust
Worcestershire Mental Health Partnership NHS Trust
Wyre Forest Primary Care Trust

Home ] Resource Shortfall Sources to 2006 ] Trusts in financial problems ] Avon, Gloucestershire and Wiltshire Strategic Health Authority ] Bedfordshire and Hertfordshire Strategic Health Authority ] Birmingham and The Black Country Strategic Health Authority ] Cheshire and Merseyside Strategic Health Authority ] County Durham and Tees Valley Strategic Health Authority ] Cumbria and Lancashire Strategic Health Authority ] Dorset and Somerset Strategic Health Authority ] Essex Strategic Health Authority ] Greater Manchester Strategic Health Authority ] Hampshire and Isle Of Wight Strategic Health Authority ] Kent and Medway Strategic Health Authority ] Leicestershire, Northamptonshire and Rutland Strategic Health Authority ] London Strategic Health Authority ] Norfolk, Suffolk and Cambridgeshire Strategic Health Authority ] North and East Yorkshire and Northern Lincolnshire Strategic Health Authority ] Northumberland, Tyne and Wear Strategic Health Authority ] Shropshire and Staffordshire Strategic Health Authority ] South West Peninsula Strategic Health Authority ] South Yorkshire Strategic Health Authority ] Surrey and Sussex Strategic Health Authority ] Thames Valley Strategic Health Authority ] Trent Strategic Health Authority ] West Midlands South Strategic Health Authority ] West Yorkshire Strategic Health Authority ] New Strategic Health Authorities ] Northern Ireland ] Scotland ] Wales ]

 East Midlands Strategic Health Authority ] East of England Strategic Health Authority ] North East Strategic Health Authority ] North West Strategic Health Authority ] South Central Strategic Health Authority ] South East Coast Strategic Health Authority ] South West Strategic Health Authority ] [ West Midlands Strategic Health Authority ] Yorkshire and the Humber Strategic Health Authority ]

Heat Map for West Midlands ] SHA forecasts 2006 07 West Midlands ]

Sheila Porter-Williams
Campaign for Health Service Democracy
Green Haven, Halfway Lane
Dunchurch
Rugby, Warwickshire CV22 6RD
sheilaCHSD@porter-williams.freeserve.co.uk